**Our Voices**
Monday, December 1, 2008
Methods of Formal Monitoring
The creation of a federal ombudsperson is one way to formally monitoring the change in policy. The role of an ombudsperson is to investigate complaints that are laid. This individual acts as a neutral third body in attempting to resolve these matters. He or she has a role that is independent of the chain of command as well as of other offices in an attempt to ensure s/he can avoid conflicts of interest.
When hearing complaints, this individual is to be impartial and listen to complains objectively and needs to be readily available to the constituency. The guiding purpose of the ombudsperson is a commitment to justice. As such s/he will have a consideration for the use and misuse of power and how that relates to the interests of individuals and larger groups.
The creation of a federal ombudsperson would have far reaching positive effects. There have been a few calls in the past for the creation of a federal ombudsperson. In May 2004 one report stated that the creation of a federal ombudsperson would actually help to reduce the "democratic deficit" that is apparent in current Canadian politics. In addition the Forum of Canadian Ombudsmen made a recommendation for the creation of a federal ombudsperson. If this were to happen, it would certainly help monitor the recommended security certificate policy change.
The Canadian Human Rights Commission will also be able to determine if we are meeting the goals and objectives of this policy change. One of the most important objectives is to ensure that human rights are not being violated as the country tries to purpose national security. The Canadian Human Rights Commission administers the Canadian Human Rights Act and will be central in determining if the policy change goals are met. In one research program conducted by the Commission, the results led them to recommend certain changes to the security certificate process. As such, the Commission would also be responsible for the continued evaluation of this issue after the changes have been made.
Formal monitoring and evaluation
One way to formally monitor the policy change is to use the federal government. In particular, the Department of Justice can play a very important role in the evaluation. The role of the Department of Justice is to support the Minister of Justice and to make sure that Canada is a just society in which there is a just and fair system. It aids the federal government in developing policy and also in reforming policy if needed.
The Department will be able to ensure that the policy change that is made to security certificates is one that is legally valid and relevant. It will regularly review the changes that are made to security certificates and call for reform if it is found that some new issues have emerged.
Similarly, the Department of National Defense will also work to monitor the effectiveness of the policy change. Since the issue security certificates were created to deal with is that of national security, the Department of National Defense has quite a vested interest in ensuring that the security of the nation is not compromised. It will work to provide advice on the effectiveness of the change and assistance in managing resulting security concerns.
The Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security is also mandated to exercise certain powers which will help in the monitoring process. This committee of the House of Commons has the power to report on studies of policies and legislation. Under Standing Order 108(2) one of the agencies this committee can study the policies and programs of is Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness Canada. This committee has already conducted similar studies. It reviewed the Anti-Terrorism Act of 2001 taking into consideration concerns about rights and limits.
Goals and Objectives
The first goal is to protect security. As a nation it is imperative that we protect the security of this country and the people within it. By abolishing security certificates we will be able to achieve this goal because it will not only continue to protect the country, but also the security of the people the certificates effect.
Under the current policy, the security of the nation is not being protected. The provisions of the certificates simply allow for the deportation of individuals who are seen as potential security threats. What is does is simply stops them from being a threat or planning a terrorist attack from within the country. This does not prevent the individual from being a threat altogether though. The individual can continue to be a threat from outside of Canada. As a result this current policy is ineffective at actually protecting and promoting security.
The second goal of the policy change is the protection of human rights. As a leader in the international arena, Canada has regularly proclaimed its acceptance of universal human rights and it has also been expected to adhere to the international human rights norms and ideal standards. To ensure the government follows these norms, Canada, along with three quarters of the world's states has accepted legal obligations to implement these rights by becoming party to the International Human Rights Covenants.
The current policy of using security certificates is in clear violation of many of these human rights. It is imperative that the government fulfill its obligations and protect the rights of both citizens and non-citizens of this country. By abolishing security certificates the individuals in question will be accorded these rights.
Sunday, November 30, 2008
...and the cons : (
Making these changes is only the first step. The macro national security framework would stay as is other than this minor change. There are issues with the macro system also that need to be addressed. We only took on one tiny piece of the puzzle because it’s just so overwhelming. But this little piece is indicative of the rest of the system.
There is no guarantee that either policy will work 100%. There may be unforeseen gaps that this policy doesn’t address, and so revisions will need to be made along the way as necessary. Gaps in security or gaps in human rights or due process can be looked at and addressed as needed.
In addition, making these changes doesn’t touch the social construction of security, terrorism, etc. that we have discussed so much on this blog. It leaves those concepts enact and unquestioned. In some ways, it reinforces those concepts as being real, necessary and true as popularly defined. Terrorism and security are socially constructed ideas that are thus understood to mean very particular things. Making this policy change doesn’t facilitate deconstructing meaning around these concepts, or look at how fear plays out. We struggled with this but decided that it was important to have something in place to deal with the potentially ‘real’ while also addressing in discourse the constructions.
The Challenge to Public Engagement
“... most Canadians will not be terribly inconvenienced by [Bill C-36]. Instead, the costs will be borne by people who find themselves targets of police suspicion because of their ethnic background, radical political views or association with immigrant communities that have ties with groups deemed to be terrorist fronts.”
- Audrey Macklin, U of T Faculty of Law (http://www.utoronto.ca/ethnicstudies/BorderlineSecurity.pdf)
It could be difficult to promote this policy. Unfortunately, because there is such a culture of fear currently, it is difficult to look at what underlies the issues. Dissent is seen as unpatriotic and divisive. Naomi Klein talks about Milton Friedman’s shock doctrine – that the time to push through really oppressive policies is when people are scared. After Sept. 11, 2001, there was a huge increase in such policies, which are still being maintained. Many people were suddenly okay with giving up their rights because they were so scared. Since most people will not be directly affected by security certificates, they are content to let a few people have their rights violated as a tradeoff for feeling more secure. We are locked into this false dichotomy that rights must be violated to ensure security. We can have both, but making the public understand this and be comfortable with it is difficult. The government has embraced the opportunity to bring in oppressive policies, and is being ‘encouraged’ to do so by other countries, such as the United States and Britain. That will be a huge barrier to overcome. Remember all the talk about Canada being a training ground for terrorists? It’s difficult to make your policies more lenient while having to defend oneself against such accusations.
Although, the policies won’t really be more lenient. I’m sure that’s how the Conservatives will see these changes, but it’s really just about making the processes transparent and fair. Another concern about these changes is that it does nothing to address the problems of the criminal justice system. The criminal justice system does not operate equitably. Racial profiling continues to be a problem, and a person of colour is much more likely to get a worse deal at each step of the process. Much more likely to be stopped by police, to be charged, to be sentenced to jail time if convicted, to be denied parole and so on. The criminal justice system may still be used to target certain groups, but at least it will be possible to integrate the process, and to appeal more readily inequities that do happen.
These are some of the potential cons we considered regarding our proposed policy change. I think the pros outweigh the cons, and many of the latter are implementation problems or larger issues, as opposed to actual problems with the policy change. Any thoughts?
The pros of our proposed policy change!
Fulfilling our goals of protecting human rights, security and due process by changing the policy would be much more consistent with federal and provincial/territorial human rights legislation. It would also be more consistent with the international commitments Canada has made to human rights, such as the International Covenant on Human Rights that was discussed in a couple of earlier posts.
By eliminating these contradictions around human rights, Canada’s credibility would be increased internationally. The USA is ridiculed and criticized worldwide for its violations of human rights. It’s the example people hold up as indicative of what’s wrong. As knowledge of Canada’s current policies grows, it too will be looked down on. The UN has published several reports criticizing Canada’s actions around other human right abuses, such as the treatment of Indigenous groups. The politicians get very embarrassed but beyond just feeling bad we need change to avoid this criticism. Canada needs to step up to make changes to bring its policies into line with human rights covenants. Canada should be setting a precedent internationally to show that human rights and due process are as important as security concerns, and that there concerns are not either/or but all/and.
Transparency and accountability are fundamental to our conception of good government. One of the functions of the judiciary is to act as a check on the government, and it is crucial that they also exemplify these principles. Our system of government relies on the judiciary to review the actions of government, and to limit the executive power of the state. They are the review for government actions, which ensures the government doesn’t just do whatever it wants to. This is called judicial authority. Relying on the criminal system rather than the security certificate process would be a return to judicial authority, a principle that is still held in discourse, although it has been much reduced in practice.
The judiciary is complicit in the government’s violations at this point, and is actually producing many of the violations. The new system would place the process back into the realm of possible transparency of process, thereby making the players accountable for their actions. Rather than operating behind closed doors, the judiciary, governmental actors, and agencies such as CSIS would have their actions up for review. Rather than not knowing why a person continues to be detained, everyone can know why and if it’s unfair, appeal. There would once again be recourse for abuse of power, and the public would be more confident in the process than all this cloak and daggers silliness. It is the lack of transparency that makes people suspicious and distrustful, and does damage to the credibility of the involved agencies.
From a purely practical perspective, having one policy to deal with all terrorist issues will be much simpler. A ‘one size fits all’ framework is a much easier and fairer process for all involved. There will be less inequities and discretionary power will not be exercised in the same way, as everyone will face the same process. We also think this will be more cost effective, because there is only one system to fund. A great deal of money is being used to fund the separate prison for security certificate detainees, even now when there is only one man being held there. This money can be better used to strengthen the existing criminal justice system.
Imprisoning people convicted of terrorism also seems to be safer than simply deporting them to other countries. If they are truly a risk, shipping them elsewhere doesn’t seem to address it at all. Theoretically, the idea of imprisoning someone guilty of a crime is supposed to punish, detain and rehabilitate them. Deportation doesn’t necessarily address these issues but does put people at risk. The money saved from unifying the systems could be used to put programming back into prisons. Many programs aimed at rehabilitation and skills training have been cut in recent years, so that the prisons do little more than detain and punish individuals. It’s important that this be changed also, and the savings from having one system could potentially go to that system to strengthen it, including putting in adequate programming.
So these are the pros of scraping the security certificates and handling all concerns under the criminal justice system. It paints a pretty attractive picture, but I’m sure you can see a few cons already from reading this. And I’ll address those in my next post!
Proposed External Monitoring (part 1)
My co-blogger previously mentioned how we would implement a new process for the accused if they are actually found guilty.
As noted in a previous post (http://maskedinjustice.blogspot.com/2008/10/how-reliable-are-secret-keepers.html ), there is clearly a need for someone to keep a check on the CSIS process and use of security certificates and treatment of evidence. Further, there is a need to ensure the rights and proper treatment of the detained and operations of a fair trial.
In addition to having monitoring of CSIS, the hearing process and ensuring the rights from bodies on ‘the inside’, there should also be external bodies to make sure there are no cracks. There should be a neutral third party. For example, we suggest the Canadian Bar Association (CBA) could take part in monitoring the hearings and ensuring the human rights of detainees are being ensured during detention.
The mandate of the Canadian Bar Association is to improve the law, the administration of justice, improve and promote access to justice and promote equality in the legal profession and in the justice system improve.
The President of the bar has, along with others, spoken out about US detainees in Guantanamo and their invitation for the detainees “to challenge the validity of their detention in US courts”. He has also supported the statement that the “war on terrorism will not and cannot be won by denying those suspected of terrorism the fundamental right of a fair opportunity to test the evidence against them.
The CBA also spoke out on the matter regarding Omar Khadr, the only Western citizen being held in Guantanamo. The CBA wrote to Harper advocating for the release of Khadr into Canada and stated that facilitating Khadr’s detainment is affront to the rule of Canadian law.
Due to The Canadian Bar Associations familiarity and activism regarding other detainees, they would be suited to advocating for the rights and fair trials of Canada’s detained non-citizens.
I leave you on this note as quoted in the Globe and Mail:
"I don't think the Canadian Bar Association has ever shied away from controversy. We are not a shy, retiring organization.” The CBA has a huge amount of credibility nationally and internationally.
Sources:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2004/aug/13/usa.guantanamo
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20070812/khadr_release_070812?s_name=&no_ads=http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070811.wmakin20811/BNStory/National/?page=rss&id=RTGAM.20070811.wmakin20811
Saturday, November 29, 2008
Our Proposed Policy Implementation Process
The two policy choices we had for the government are already existing policies that would just need to be slightly modified. The first step of the implementation process is for the federal government to initiate a repeal process of security certificate provisions of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. Only the provisions relating to security certificates need to be repealed, to make the changes we recommend. The rest of the IRPA would stay as is. This would need to be timed so as to allow the next steps to take place, but we would expect this occurs in a timely manner. The detainments are years long at this point, the evidence was presumably gathered prior to arrest, and allowing an injustice to continue indefinitely is not acceptable. The whole reason we recommend these changes is to bring them into line with humane policies, and this must be done intelligently and expediently.
Concurrently, the Attorney General needs to begin criminal proceedings for each person on a security certificate against whom there exists sufficient evidence to lay charges. The repeal of the IRPA provisions must be timed to allow this process to happen. The men currently on certificates have been subject to them for many years, so it should just be a matter of putting together the available information, if any, and officially charging them under the Criminal Code. The Attorney General is one of the people who originally signed the Security Certificate, so they would also already be familiar with the cases. Through the criminal code process, continued detention or conditions of release can be worked out, akin to anyone else being charged criminally. There is a process of applying for bail upon arrest, along with an appeal process for those denied release, or who want to appeal their bail conditions.
So once a period of time has passed to allow the compilation of the criminal case, the IRPA clauses could be revoked, and simultaneously the current security certificates would be dropped completely. This also means that the concurrent deportation proceedings would be null and void. Should the government want to seek a deportation order, it would be up to them to do so under the existing IRPA deportation procedures rules after the individual has been criminally convicted.
I’ve talked about implementation as though there is evidence and guilt on the part of these men, but we really don’t know that. The secrecy of the proceedings and the lack of information actually make it seem unlikely that there will be any criminal charges laid or guilt found. However the point in making these policy changes is to protect security and human rights while ensuring due process for both those who have committed “terrorist” acts and those who have not but for some reason or other, face suspicion. Implementing these policy changes, as above, are a first step towards meeting our goals and objectives of protecting security, human rights and due process.
Friday, November 28, 2008
How Do We Create Awareness? Let me show the ways....
The Office of the High Commissioner of Human Rights made suggestions on how to create awareness:
- Publicize the human rights of human detainees and which have been denied
- Create a documentary hightlighting the matter and violation of human rights treaties
- Facilitate roundtable discussions and training regarding creating awareness. Include local social services in the event.
- Organize events and campaigns with keynote speakers such as former detainees
- Organize information campaigns for journalists, regarding the impact of detention on the individual and their families
- Contact talk shows and discussion shows and ask them to speak on detainees
- Arrange meetings, discussions with organizations and the government
- Produce radio shows and newspapers and newsletters
- Suggest the topic of detention and human rights as a theme in educational theater
- Identify feature stories. Highlight moving or shocking situations, and prepare former detainees who are willing and able to give media interviews on detention-related issues.
Further, the online community is a great way to create public awareness. An electronic form of 'by mouth' is Facebook Groups, such as: Adil Charkaoui - The People's Commission on Immigration Security Measures can easily create awareness. Join the group, ask others to join.
Also the creation of websites for public awareness is very effective. Refer to: The Coalition Justice for Adil Charkaoui (http://www.adilinfo.org/?q=en/taxonomy/term/3). For example, they are advertising an event on Dec 10th to gain solidarity against 'secret trials'.
Overall, there are many ways, from detailed to simple, to create public awareness. See the following link to learn more:
http://www.ohchr.org/EN/UDHR/Documents/60UDHR/detention_infonote_2.pdf
The Visitor
Spread The Word
All of these people have longer ‘shelf-life’ than our literal neighbours who are being oppressed without knowledge of justification. They’re less than a flash in the frying pan.
As you know from the previous posts, there have been people who have been detained for more than 5 years. Where is their coverage?
We need to engage Non-Governmental Organizations, academic institutions and human rights defenders (social services), the onling community and of course the media. Education from these groups include events like ‘Dignity and Justice for Detainees Week’ where an opportunity is available for creating awareness of human right standards being violated and rallying for our government’s implementation of human rights treaties.
What is Dignity and Justice for Detainees week? Dignity and Justice for Detainees Week aims to highlight detention and encourage improvements in the conditions of detainees through workshops and publicity campaigns. It normally takes place during the first week of October.
The United Nations Human Rights High Commissioner said, "We are not against prisons and detention centres per se – but they should be reserved for those who really deserve to be there according to the extensive, detailed and fundamentally sound international standards governing criminal justice”
What avenues do you want to use to create awareness in the general public? The mainstream and alternative media must be used, along with the direct approach.
Tips on how to go about this are coming up….
Source: http://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DignityandJusticeDetaineesWeek.aspx
Tuesday, November 25, 2008
Fwd from TASC re: National Day of Action
Join us Wednesday December 10 (or as near to that date as you can) to call for the abolition of "security certificates" and deportations to torture.
As Canada marks International Human Rights Day this December 10, secret rendition-to-torture hearings will be continuing in the nation's capital. The public portions of those secret hearings, show trials in which an individual is alleged to be a threat but is not given any reasons why, have been ongoing, even though the Supreme Court of Canada declared security certificates unconstitutional in February, 2007. Such hearings have been a hallmark of Canadian immigration law for decades.
Many people thought that since four of the five individuals detained (Mohammad Mahjoub, Mahmoud Jaballah, Mohamed Harkat, Adil Charkaoui) under these medieval certificates were home with their families that somehow the suffering has ended. Far from it. The daily humiliation of being forced to wear tracking devices strapped to their ankles, the inability to go to the corner store to buy a litre of milk without government permission or having your mother accompany you, the over-the-top surveillance by state agents (everything from the cameras located both inside and outside the residence, tapping of phones and opening of mail to constantly snapping pictures of the men and their families while on approved "outings,") and the manner in which these "conditions of release" have actually served to jail the men's wives, parents, and children, clearly show that the pattern of repression continues to grow, isolating them from their communities as they fight deportation to torture.
Meanwhile, Hassan Almrei remains indefinitely detained in the most expensive solitary confinement cell in Canada, Kingston's Immigration Holding Centre (aka Guantanamo North).
Security certificates represent two-tier justice, the lowest-standard available because of the fact that those affected are refugees and permanent residents. The addition of a so-called "special advocate" does nothing to address the fundamentally flawed and unfair nature of the process, because the detainee is no closer to seeing the basis of the secret file. The fact that the same judges hearing these cases have all made adverse findings against the secret trial five in the past leaves the door open to a clear apprehension of bias. And the Chief Justice of the Federal Court muses aloud about why such hearings need to have the highest standards applied!
Join us December 10 to remind the Canadian public, government officials, and federal court judges that secret trials and deportations to torture cannot be subject to amendments and tinkering: they must be abolished.
Getting Involved.
1. Already, events are planned in London, Toronto, Fredericton, Ottawa, and Montreal. If you would like to hold an event in your community, contact us at tasc@web.ca, and we can help you with press releases, handouts for your action, and specific suggestions.
2. Join Federal Court Watch, a new initiative that invites you as a member of the public into the courts to monitor and document the abuses that go on in the public portions of these Kafkaesque trials. See http://www.adilinfo.org/en/federal-court-watch
Endorsed by: Campaign to Stop Secret Trials in Canada, Justice for Adil, Justice for Mohamed Harkat Committee
Toronto Event: Gather at CSIS with Santa Claus on Wednesday, December 10, 4:30-5:30 pm, for a Sing-Out Against Secret Trials. Join us for new renditions of those holiday favourites, including Rudolf the Racist MP, Struggling in a Winter Wonderland, CSIS Spies are Tracking You Down, and the classic chestnut, The 12 Days of IRPA. Info: tasc@web.ca
Montreal event: Gather at Federal Court at 12 noon, December 10, details at www,adilinfo.org, justiceforadil@riseup.net
Events also planned in Ottawa, London, Fredericton, and other cities that have yet to finalize plans. Please join us wherever you are!!
Monday, November 17, 2008
The Loss of Faith
A legitimate government has become the hegemonic political ideal in contemporary society. For a country to be seen as such, its government needs to sustain economic growth, promote political participation, and promote respect for the rights of the people in the country. Canada, like many other countries, has only recently begun seeking legitimacy. The reason for this is the shift to democratic rule from that of an authoritative one. Instead of having power based on natural order or a divine grant, the government sought power by appealing to a bottom-up authorization from its people. When we have a democratically elected government and political policies that are recognized by the people, we are provided with a regime which we view as legitimate. Having civil and political rights are key to this because they provide transparency and accountability to the people.
It is clear however, that by having security certificates, this is not happening. It is extremely important for the people to have the ability to see and understand the workings of their government and the policies it chooses to implement. When Canadians see how security certificates are shrouded in secrecy they are forced to understand the lack of transparency in the system. Not only are the individuals who are under suspicion not allowed to view the evidence against them, Canadians are not privileged with this information either.
Citizens also lose faith in their government when they see it violating international agreements. International covenants are often simply agreements between consenting nations that are hard to enforce. Many countries break these agreements and violate the covenants and at times there is little the international community can do to enforce the rules or punish the violators. Some people criticize such international covenants since they are not always enforceable.
However it needs to be realized that countries do not agree to such covenants only as a way of appearing legitimate to the international world. They do so because it also allows them to be legitimate to their own citizens. By consenting to certain agreements they give themselves certain goals they need to achieve and a measure of excellence. Citizens of a country can look to these agreements and hold their governments accountable to the rules to which they agreed. So when Canada sees its government clearly violating these rules and not keeping its word to the international world they lose faith in it. How can the government be expected to keep its word to its own citizens when it apparently lies to the entire world?
Saturday, November 8, 2008
Unfair Dealing film link
You-tube has the video called Unfair Dealing if you want to watch it in parts, or the full version is available here: http://www.weingarten.ca/unfair_dealing.htm
Friday, November 7, 2008
Measuring the impact of the policy
Positivist research is not appropriate to the review, because it obscures the political nature of the research. It pretends to be value neutral, while humanist researchers put their values on the table for review. Since their underlying values are in the open, the assumptions they make are open for discussion and interrogation. In adopting a humanist perspective, the researchers will be able to examine the social construction of terrorism, terrorists, security, etc. and will allow the researchers to take a human rights based stance, rather than pretending to be neutral objective observers. It is important that the researchers ally themselves with a human rights focus to stop the abuses from continuing.
The Neilsen Task Force review in 1984 looked at how the federal government evaluates its programs, and included the recommendation that evaluations should question the program’s basic rationale. I think this is very important in reviewing the Security Certificate provision of the IRPA. We’ve talked about its apparent goals and objectives, and how the policy does not mesh with them. Were the researchers to examine the program’s basic rationale, recommendations could be made that would answer their goals and eliminate the most egregious of human rights abuses.
The negative effects to date on certain people have been justified by a utilitarian or social contract approach to society. The ends justify the means – for the greater good, some must suffer – to live in society, (some) people give up rights… Adopting a human rights approach does not support any of these philosophies. If it’s wrong, then it’s wrong – there isn’t room for justification. There is room to develop a policy that addresses the security concerns without compromising human and civil rights.
I believe these detentions have been motivated more by racism and xenophobia than any real threat to Canada, but even if there is a threat, I believe people’s human rights need to be protected while addressing it. The undesired effects of these policies otherwise will be enormous. Look at the experiences of the wrongly convicted – readapting to society after everything you believe in has been proven wrong and taken from you is a hugely difficult task. And for Canada as a whole, a society that condones abuse, secrets and torture will only reproduce and reinforce itself over the years to come creating something even more grotesque.
(Info on policy evaluation comes from Weshues, A. Evalutaing Social Welfare Policies and Programs in Westhues, A. (Ed). 2006. Canadian Social Policy Issues and Perspectives. Waterloo, Ontario: Wilfred Laurier University, and from class discussions around her essay.)
Thursday, November 6, 2008
Federal Court ruling on constitutional challenge
The case was based on the concerns of special advocates regarding their ability to effectively do their jobs while subject to the “gag-orders” in place preventing them from sharing classified information with detainees and their lawyers, among others including staff, and other special advocates. Permission must even be sought from the court to continue to communicate with the detainee and their lawyer after the special advocate has viewed the ‘secret information’, severely limiting the ability of special advocates to serve the needs of the detainees.
Chief Justice Lutfy determined that it was necessary to wait and see how “the role of special advocates evolve” based on interpretations of the law by presiding judges faced with these decisions. However, he did clarify that special advocates working on the same case could share information with each other. He noted that there were five ongoing certificate proceedings and while these were underway it was premature to rule on the impact of the legislative changes.
Lorne Waldman, the lawyer representing Hassan Almrei (and a spec ial advocate himself), is not ruling out another constitutional challenge once the provisions have been in place for a little longer.
This ruling appears to mean that the men subject to security certificates will be forced to wait until their rights are further violated and that the system fails them even more before they will be in a position to challenge their situation. It is not enough that these special advocates, all seasoned lawyers approved by the government to play this role, are arguing that they can’t do their jobs with the current limitations placed on them. They will somehow have to prove the system’s failures, which will depend in part on the ways in which individual judges interpret the new provisions, while detainees bear the consequences of this delay.
Article regarding Federal Court decision: www.macleans.ca/artcile.jsp?content=n1103111A
Saturday, November 1, 2008
Different Response for Different Folks!
Food for thought.....
Since the theme of the day is differential response and treatment, I urge you to read the following and consider what the response might be if the person was an Arab.
"Joseph Egan doesn't think he'll ever board a Greyhound bus again after a passenger threatened to behead him Friday.
"I moved to the middle of the bus and a woman said 'If you go to the bus driver, I'll cut your head off,' " Egan said from a hotel in Winnipeg.
"We said nothing directly to her," Egan said.
A 41-year-old woman has been charged with possession of a weapon and uttering threats, RCMP said."
http://www.canada.com/topics/news/national/story.html?id=aba88ea9-d8a8-4b98-b89c-e5cc85543d74
Citizenship and Due Process
The criminal code contains provisions against terrorism including prohibitions against fund raising, participation, and holding property for terrorist groups. Related to this is the creation of a list of groups deemed terrorist by the federal government, which changes over time. The so-called Toronto 18 were charged under these provisions of the criminal code. The potential sentence is life in jail. Included are the usual due process rules around the right to retain counsel at any time during the proceeding, having to see a judge within a certain amount of time, and the right to be released, unless they think you won’t show up for court or you’re a safety risk. It seems this section applies to both citizens and permanent residents. Permanent residents can be prosecuted either way, presumably at the discretion of those investigating (or perhaps who is investigating). The criminal code process is quite different from the security certificate process which only non-citizens face.
Wesley Wark wrote a paper for the Canadian Human Rights Commission about National Security and Human Rights. The Minister of Public Safety and the Minister of Citizenship and Immigration are supposed to issue a security certificate where there is a threat to Canadian security, a violation of human or international rights, serious criminality, or organized criminality by a non-citizen. The CHRC is very concerned about the broad definition of terrorism combined with the removal of civil rights for those accused of terrorism. The combination of these two things could result in it being used to stifle opposition or target people based on the political and social climate, rather than any real threat. I’m being pretty gentle saying ‘could.’ As described before, the historical detention of people with certificates has focused on certain groups, for example, the detention of Iraqi people during the early 1990s. “The right to liberty and freedom from arbitrary arrest and detention are fundamental human rights to which Canada has subscribed under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and in our Charter of Rights and Freedoms.” The rights under these agreements are supposed to apply to everyone within Canada, as well as everyone affected by Canada’s actions.
Depriving certain people of these rights by using a different mechanism to pursue terrorism charges doesn’t appear to meet any reasonable goals. If the goal is to deport ‘criminals’ an application could be made after conviction. If the concern is that spreading knowledge will endanger security, then why is it only terrorism by non-citizens that poses this risk? Either it should apply to all people, or no one. The discretionary powers and the different types of terrorism charges demonstrate how the laws are based in a xenophobic belief system. We obviously not just talking about security here. If there actually is a threat, than a coherent argument needs to be made.
Wark’s paper: http://www.chrc-ccdp.ca/research_program_recherche/ns_sn/toc_tdm-en.asp
Monday, October 27, 2008
Creating the 'Other'
When we created the Indian Act, there was a denial of right to vote, purchase land, and engage in traditional ceremonies. Canada's first peoples were forced to relocate, pushed aside to reserves and were restricted from civil and political rights.
When runaway slaves were migrating from America to Canada with great promises of better land, education and rights, they were again segregated in their schools and communities and had limited property rights.
Let us not forget Komagata Maru. I bet they didn't teach you this gem of Canadian History in grade 10! In 1914 South Asians were detained on a steamer boat for 2 months on the coast of Vancouver before they were eventually denied entry into Canada. During this time, exclusion laws in Canada were designed to keep Asian immigrants out.
During World War II, a number of Japanese Canadians (75% of which had Canadian citizenship) were incarcerated, forced to work and had their property taken from them. If they did not enter incarceration, they would be deported. After 2 years, they were released and had no compensation until the late 80s. The reason for the government’s action? Security reasons; the Japanese-Canadians may have been a National Threat. Believe it or not, Canadian Parliamentarian Ian Mackenzie said in 1944, "It is the government’s plan to get these people out of B.C. as fast as possible. It is my personal intention, as long as I remain in public life, to see they never come back here. Let our slogan be for British Columbia: ‘No Japs from the Rockies to the seas".
( http://www.crr.ca/divers-files/en/pub/faSh/ePubFaShLegRac.pdf )
The security certificate is our latest instalment of institutionalized discrimination and racism which allows the Canadian Security Intelligence Service to have anyone thrown in jail who might be deemed a national threat, even if the evidence is weak (as we’ve seen in the previous posts). Such institutionalized discrimination leads to racial profiling. When we see our authority figures doing this, it sets an example of ‘what to be aware of’, or what to ‘beware’ of.
We see this institutionalized discrimination at it’s finest in the airport. You will find the lines for ‘random’ checks of suitcases long and populated by Arabs, Muslims, individuals with Muslim sounding names and even Sikhs (from a different part of the world, and of a different religion but
indistinguishable by the untrained security personnel eye).
Family Guy highlighted this issue: http://www.humorscore.com/videos/Family_Guy_Videos/Family_Guy_-_Johnny_Quest
It’s interesting. In this clip, the writers imply that you should not even be yourself, just to avoid security personnel from jumping to conclusions. It’s true. There are many Muslims out there who feel the need to dress in a traditionally non-Islamic manner to avoid the hassle.
Consider the news media. These terrorists organizations are sometimes called ‘Islamists’. Now what in the world is an ‘Islamist’?! It’s not a word that these groups have used, because it’s not even proper grammar. It’s like saying ‘Christanity’ist’ or ‘Hinduism’ist’. These were terms conjured by either the government or the media. These people are not categorized as terrorists anymore, they’re being defined by their religion, which now applies 1.5 billion people or one-fifth of the world’s population. Their label for the enemy has suddenly expanded from ‘terrorists’ to a term that will be associated with adherents of a religion.
If our authority figures show us that these people cannot be trusted, we will also develop distrust for these groups. As a result these groups feel alienated and will tend to segregate themselves, only widening the gap between what is being created as ‘us’ and ‘the other’. We no longer think of ourselves as ‘black’, ‘white’, ‘Asian’, ‘Spanish’ etc. We’re now Canadian and Arab.
It has happened in the past and it is currently being perpetuated against Muslims and Arabs in Canada. Security certificates are no longer just a security measure, they’ve become a justification for discrimination and racism.
Sunday, October 26, 2008
Is Canada ignoring its international obligations?
It is evident that security certificates are a gross violation of human rights. As some of the other posts have explained the accused are detained for unknown reasons and are subject to inhuman conditions while being imprisoned. There have also been numerous reports of torture and requests for basic necessities which go ignored.
Recognizing human rights and the reason why we have them are vital for a democratic and just nation. After World War Two, international agreements and covenants were implemented to ensure that everyone was accorded certain inherent rights. The Universal Deceleration of Human Rights was created to achieve this goal. It was adopted by the United Nations General Assembly on December 10, 1948. The current treatment of the detainees in Canada is in clear violation of the declaration. Article 9 states that "no one shall be subject to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile," and Article 10 follows "everyone is entitled in full equity to a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal, in the determination of his rights and obligations and of any criminal charge against him." It is evident that by using security certificates, Canada is violating these articles.
Canada is also violating the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights which was entered into force on March 23, 1976. Article 14 of this covenant says that everyone who is charged with a criminal offence is entitled "to be informed promptly and in detail in a language which he understands of the nature and cause of the charge against him." Again, the detainees being held in Canada are not always informed of the reason for their detention. They are often left in the dark.
By agreeing to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights Canada also agreed to the declarations "standard of achievement for all peoples and nations." Following the agreement shows the legitimacy of a government. By not following it, the Canadian government is decreasing its political legitimacy. The ideals of this declaration need to be upheld and it is the responsibility of both the government and the citizens of this country to make sure that Canada fulfills its obligations. We cannot simply theoretically agree to a monumental document and then proceed to do as we please. It is essential that Canada does as it has promised to the international world and uphold the reputation that we have. The reason for upholding it is not because it will make us "look good" to the rest of the world but rather because it is good.
For more information please refer to Universal Human Rights In Theory and Practice, Second Edition by Jack Donnelly
Canada's role in the the American War on Terror
It is extremely important to look at the relationship Canada has with the United States due to the fact that this relationship plays a big role in the policies this country makes to deal with security issues. As it has been explained in previous posts, security certificates have long been used in Canada even though they did not gain too much attention until after September 11. After the terrorist attacks in the United States the American government took a new stance on national security. The United States strengthened their security laws and implemented strict rules regarding security. They then instigated the War on Terror in their attempts to make the country a safer place. I’m sure we can all remember when George W. Bush made his speech on November 6, 2001 about protecting America and the American way of life. In the speech he stated that "you are either with us or against us in the fight against terror," clearly distinguishing the only two camps other countries could belong to. This meant that Canada would have to quickly decide which camp it wanted to be a part of. Not surprisingly, the Canadian government quickly tried to align itself with the former camp.
As America’s neighbour, Canada plays a very important role in the American War on Terror. Canada’s proximity to the United States makes it strategically powerful. The border we share with the United States is the longest border in the world and one that allows for numerous people to cross each year. As fears grew in America over who was getting into their country and the entry points they used to gain access, the American government quickly looked to their neighbour to the North. The American media wrongly reported that some of the 9/11 hijackers had entered the country through the Canadian border. Border security was given high priority and was seen as something that needed to be tightened in order to prevent potential terrorists from entering the country in the future.
However, putting more security measures at the 49th parallel could have negative consequences for Canada. If the American government imposed measures that were too strict at the Canadian border, the Canadian economy would suffer. The United States is our largest trading partner and having an open border is part of the reason for this. The Canadian government needed to show the Americans that Canada was not harboring terrorists and that Canada would do its part in making sure our country was terrorist free.
The years after 9/11 were an extremely tense period on an international level where countries all over the world were trying to show the global giant that is America that they were on the "right" side of this war. As the Americans criticized the seemingly lacks security measures in Canada, the Canadian government attempted to rectify the situation by proving that we too were doing our part to fight the terrorists. The United States created the Patriot Act and Canada responded with Bill C-36.
This makes me wonder why Canada feels the need to allows follow suite with the Americans. I understand the role American plays in our economy and how maintaining good relations with our southern neighbour are vital to our continued national prosperity. At the same time however it also seems that we often do what America wants us to do even when it is detrimental to ourselves.